Friday, November 6, 2009

Representative Democracy- Really?

Do you really believe in representative democracy, "One man, one vote" or the ever popular "No taxation without representation?" When less than 30% usually vote for the winning candidate, how representative can that be? Do the math a voter turnout over 50% is unusually high. Then the winning candidate gets about 50% of that vote. And that is just counting the registered voters!

UPDATE In the recent highly publicised NY district 23 race here are the stats for the winner:
Bill Owens (D, WFP): – 60,671; 50.0%
Since a congressional district is almost 700,000, that is less than 10%.

So do you think it is more valid to assume those who do not vote are approve of either candidate, or just don't want to waste time picking the "lesser of two weasles."

I see that one could go one of two ways. A. As far as being representative our current system is at least 75% a failure and should be overhauled. OR B. Representative democracy is just propaganda to replace "divine right of kings" in order to provide legitimacy and stability to a government. (Option C- it works well enough, don't mess with it collapses to option B)

If you go for option A, here is the "Simple Solution to Complex Problem"tm for the day.
========================
Initially I considered eliminating congressional districts and having the reps elected at large in each state. As far as I can tell they are not constitutionally mandated.
Representatives shall be apportioned among the several States according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each State, excluding Indians not taxed.[5]

Article I additionally provides that:

The Number of Representatives shall not exceed one for every thirty Thousand, but each State shall have at Least one Representative...[4]
But recently I devised a more elegant solution.
I Representatives
  1. Everyone who gets more than 30,000 votes is elected.
  2. In legislative votes, each rep gets one vote for every person who voted FOR them. (or one vote for every 30,000 and a fractional vote for the remainder).
  3. The state legislatures will assign "red-shirt congressment" to fill out any unused appropriated representative slots. RSCs can participate in committee hearings, and propose legislation but have an automatic NO or REPEAL vote.
  4. Votes for a unelected candidate can be moved to a winning candidate within 2 months time by the voter, otherwise they go into the RSC pool for the state.
II Senators.
  1. Each senators legislative vote is proportional to the percentage of the population of their state that voted for them.

Sunday, January 4, 2009

Government Spending Reform

I was looking at TigerHawk's tax proposal blog today. One comment was that all of the proposals are just 'rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic"- the real problem is spending. How true. If the max was 1-2%, do you think taxes would be that big an issue? Now I am a fan of the FairTax, but the commenter was on point.

I've also been listening to EconTalk podcast and thinking about free-market theory and incentives. Why is there so much pork in federal spending? Because bringing home the pork benefits and is rewarded by the local voters. Thrift in your representative has no direct benefit. So it is time for a DSSSFCP (Dowlan Smith's Simple Solution For Complex Problems.)

1. Representatives are responsible for the spending of all tax revenue for their district.
2. Tax revenues for a district that are unspent are rebated to the tax payers of that district.

How does it work? There would be two types of spending bills. Voluntary and Compulsory-Proportional.

Voluntary bills- The rep not only votes yea or nay, but how much of his district's revenue to go towards the bill.

Compulsory-Proportional bills- the same percentage of each district's taxes is directed for that bill. This requires 2/3 majority plus 1% for each percent of districts whose spending will exceed their revenue for the year. This would max out at 90%.