We really need jury trial reform. Video tape all the testimony and evidence without the jury present. Then all the objections can be edited out. If the objection is sustained then the offending question/statement is also erased, otherwise just the time wasting objection.
I think this would make the trial run faster because lawyers would know that (except for opening and closing statements) anything that is not a question will probably get edited out and cannot be used as a backdoor to introduce prejudicial material.
An unedited version would also be available for independent review in appeals.
Perhaps give each lawyer an objection/asked and answered remote and the judge a sustained/overruled remote to tag the tape to facilitate the editing process.
The edited tape would be much faster for the jury to watch and they can immediately review anything they miss. Until lawyers get used to the new format, I bet the trial time to video time will be at least a 2 to 1 ratio. The jury viewing could be done at the end or perhaps concurrently on evenings or weekends.
This would also solve hung juries, mistrial, retrials to some extent, because the tape could just be shown to 12 new jurors and not have the problem of rounding up the witnesses again.
Since a video retrial might be too easy we might require a majority or super majority for conviction. A conventional retrial or just additional testimony and cross examination could be added if there were additional evidence. (Closing statements could be edited in that case also)
you could also minimize the emotional tug that defendants can have on juries and make the decisions more objective.
ReplyDeleteand it would create jobs--someone has to edit that shiznit. hey, i know someone looking for a job!